Mustard Plug
Mustard Plug has 20 shows on record on HearHear, and 6 members have logged seeing them live. Next show: Nov 21, 2026 at Starland Ballroom, Sayreville, NJ.
Upcoming Mustard Plug shows
- Nov 21, 2026 — Starland Ballroom, Sayreville, NJ · with Goldfinger, The Planet Smashers, Catbite, Millington
- Nov 22, 2026 — Rumba Cafe, Columbus, Ohio · with City Sidestep
- Jan 16, 2027 — Gothic Theatre, Englewood, Colorado
Recent Mustard Plug shows
- Oct 25, 2026 — Various Venues, Gainesville, Florida, FL · Fest 24 2026
- Oct 24, 2026 — Various Venues, Gainesville, Florida, FL · Fest 24 2026
- Sep 23, 2026 — Horseshoe Tavern, Toronto, ON · with K-Man & the 45s, Arcade Allstars
- Jul 19, 2026 — Metro, Chicago, Illinois · with Jeff Rosenstock
- Dec 28, 2025 — Bottom Lounge, Chicago, IL · with The Solutions
- Dec 3, 2025 — Rumba Cafe, Columbus, Ohio · with The Raging Nathans, Lustkill
- Nov 9, 2024 — Middle East Downstairs, Cambridge, MA · with Catch 22
- Nov 6, 2024 — Rumba Cafe, Columbus, Ohio · with The Iron Roses, The Raging Nathans
- Dec 13, 2023 — Rumba Cafe, Columbus, Ohio · with Scott B // Ska Bees
- Oct 28, 2023 — Vivid Music Hall, Gainesville, Florida · The Fest 21 - Day 2 2023 · with Paint It Black, Pkew Pkew Pkew, Direct Hit!, Dillinger Four
- Aug 23, 2018 — House of Blues, Cleveland, Ohio · with The Mighty Mighty Bosstones
- Sep 11, 2015 — Douglass Park, Chicago, IL · Riot Fest 2015
- Oct 26, 2012 — The Florida Theater / High Dive / 8 Seconds / Loosey's, Gainesville, Florida · Fest 11 2012 · with Braid, Ceremony, Cheap Girls, Code Orange Kids
- Dec 28, 2011 — Metro, Chicago, Illinois
- Oct 12, 2008 — Congress Theater, Chicago, IL · Riot Fest 2008
Latest Mustard Plug setlist
Dec 28, 2025 at Bottom Lounge, Chicago, IL
- Someday, Right Now
- Aye Aye Aye
- Box
- The All-Nighter
- Vampire
- Go
- Yesterday
- Fall Apart
- Hit Me! Hit Me!
- Why Does It Have to Be So Hard?
- You
- Waiting Room
- We're Gunna Take on the World
- Mendoza
- Over the Edge
- On and On
- Last Christmas / Careless Whisper
- Brain on Ska
- Mr. Smiley
- Beer (Song)
- Roots Radicals
Setlist via setlist.fm.
Venues Mustard Plug has played most
- Rumba Cafe, Columbus, Ohio — 3 shows
- Metro, Chicago, Illinois — 2 shows
- Various Venues, Gainesville, Florida, FL — 2 shows